Talk:The Battle of the Gwathló

Let's not care about Erestor's descent. In the books and canon, he is a noldor. In LOTR Strategy Game, he is a Noldor. So I say go with that. I'll go with Maglor being deleted, but not Erestor. However, it does say on wikipedia that Maglor dwelt by the shores of Beleriand and went to live with Elrond for a time at Imladris. So I know he wasn't just jacking off into the sea for the Silmaril--he had to do something in the next ages.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maglor this shows maglor lived with Elrond in the paragraph labeled Earlier Legendarium. However, the paragraph where he suicides is uncanonical, if we go with what is published. And the published text is what ultimately counts. Not some off scree note! Moran half valar (talk) 17:53, August 19, 2018 (UTC)