Talk:Talion

I disagree about Celebrimbor. In fact Tolkien dtates that a few elvish fear might refuse to go to the halls of mandos and become poltergeists.some of the evil spirits the necromancers use to " ensoul" their creatures might actually be elvish or orcish fear rather than mortal undead. If celebrimbor was heavily traumatized from saurons torture and guilt ridden because of his ringmaking that MIGHT have the impact on him regusing to go to mandos and becomeing a wraith. The problem with shadow of war is rather the undead ranger Talion, a "half-wraith" seriuosly? Mortal men go to illuvstar after a brief stay in mandos and there are very few exceptions to this rule, one is the nazgul and a few lesser wraith, the second is the oathbreakers. One could argue about barrow wights or the spirits in the dead marshes - maybe, but a creature such as talion would hardly be possible.He would have to be either a full-wraith, if something could "bind" his soul to arda and delay his departure for some time, or he would habe to be a dead body, animited by Celebrimbor's poltergeist, but that would be Celebrimbor animating a dead body and no talion!--Haerangil (talk) 13:15, December 8, 2018 (UTC)